Why Your Coffee Tastes Burnt

Coffee brewing is both a science and an art; however, it’s pretty difficult to achieve precise results every time. Of course, no one wants to drink a bad cup of coffee, but sometimes your coffee may taste burnt. 

Over-roasted coffee beans, stale coffee, or brewing temps that are too high can all lean to a burnt flavor. First, use a thermometer to confirm your brewing temperature is appropriate to your brew method, and if you’re using an automatic drip brewer consider using grounds from a lighter roast.

Many of us have experienced a burnt taste in our coffee. Let’s look at the reasons that can ruin the taste of your coffee and what steps you can take to improve it. 

What Causes Coffee to Have a Burnt Taste? 

Hand brewing coffee with a bright red color espresso coffee machine

There’re several reasons why your favorite brew doesn’t taste as good as you want it to. Let’s look at some common reasons that can make your coffee taste burnt:

Over-roasted Beans 

Dark roast coffee, and especially french roasts like this one (on Amazon) are most likely to get over-roasted as it goes through multiple cycles. Although light roast coffee is much harder to burn, its taste can be more bitter. You can switch to a medium roast as there’s less chance of burnt beans.

Overheated Coffee

Many automatic brewers are designed with hot plates that are typically a flavor killer. Leaving your coffee pot on the hot plate can keep it warm but will continue the extraction process and turn good coffee into a burnt, bitter brew.

Stale Coffee

The oxidization process starts once the coffee beans are roasted. One of the best ways to prevent oxidization is to keep the beans in sealed bags, so they aren’t exposed to air. But once you open the bag, the oxidization process starts, which is faster for coffee grounds as they have a larger surface area. 

If you prefer ground coffee, keep in mind that it goes stale faster than whole beans that are ground fresh. You can brew stale coffee perfectly, but your coffee will still taste burnt. Even though the beans aren’t under or over-roasted, you’re still left with a disagreeable aftertaste. 

Dirty Appliances

It’s also essential to keep your coffee machine clean, as residue build-up can seep into your beverage and ruin its taste. You may not notice much difference at first. However, if you don’t clean your appliance regularly, the taste of your coffee will worsen. 

How Can You Avoid Burnt Coffee? 

Following are some ways that can protect you from suffering through burnt coffee:

Don’t Leave Your Coffee Machine Unattended

It’s better to keep an eye on your coffee machine while it’s working. Suppose you can’t stay while your coffee brews; set a timer to avoid running your machine for longer. Turn off the machine once the coffee is brewed to prevent overheating the liquid. 

Monitor the Temperature

There’s no denying that the correct water temperature is essential for a great-tasting cup of coffee. The temperature of 96 degrees Centigrade or 205 Fahrenheit is ideal for any cup of coffee. 

Too hot water could destroy your coffee beans’ subtle flavors and volatile oils. Conversely, water that is too cool can result in coffee that’s under-extracted, leaving you with a weak brew or sour taste

An easy solution to this problem is to invest in a simple kitchen thermometer like this one (on Amazon). However, if you don’t have access to a thermometer, bring the water to a boil and leave it for almost 30 seconds before brewing.   

Choose a Reputable Roaster

Good quality coffee beans are a prerequisite for a great-tasting cup of coffee. To avoid roasting-related burnt coffee flavors, be sure to buy your coffee beans from a reputable roaster. Try different roasters and shop around before deciding which coffee is perfect for you. 

Brew What You Need

Coffee tastes best when it’s fresh. By brewing too much coffee, you might feel that you’re saving time, but you’ll be left with a brew that’s unpleasant and tastes burnt. 

Some Brewing Techniques for a Better Cup of Coffee 

These days, you can brew coffee in several ways:

Pour Over Method

This method is best for anyone who prefers a short but focused morning ritual. A coffee cup produced using this method has a smooth and delicate texture with an expressive and clear flavor. It requires care and focus on mastering the pour technique and is perfect for people who aren’t afraid to experiment.  

Cold Brew Method

This method is quite simple, as ground coffee is immersed in room temperature water for almost 12 hours before it’s poured out through a filter. Coffee prepared with this method is crisp and refreshing, with a light and silky mouthfeel.

How to Make Burnt Coffee Taste Better 

You can improve the taste of your burnt coffee with the help of the following:

  • Turn your coffee into a latte by adding milk.
  • Add sugar and cream to cut down on the unpalatable flavor.
  • Cinnamon, which is often used in desserts, also helps to reduce the bitterness of your coffee. By adding cinnamon to your coffee, you’re tricking your taste buds into thinking that your coffee isn’t too bitter.
  • A pinch of salt not only reduces the bitterness of your coffee but also helps revive coffee that tastes stale. Interestingly, salt has proven to be a better compound compared to sugar for reducing bitterness.
  • Adding a squeeze of lemon to your coffee can also help counteract the bitterness. You can also try putting a lemon or orange rind in your coffee pot.  

What Else Makes Coffee Tastes Bad?

Easter breakfast concept

In addition to the above, some other reasons can make your coffee taste bad. It may be because your:

Coffee Equipment isn’t Right

Using the right coffee gear helps to get the best results. Although you can make a great-tasting espresso without an espresso machine, it might just not have the accuracy and consistency produced by an actual machine.  

Drinking coffee from a plastic cup also affects its taste. So it’s better to use ceramic or glass mugs for drinking coffee or stainless steel travel mugs while you’re on the go.

Tap Water Doesn’t Taste Great

Particles in your tap water can significantly affect the flavor of your coffee. Be sure to use filtered water for your coffee, as it tastes better.

Grind Size isn’t Ideal

Having a perfect grind size can make a huge difference to your coffee taste. It should be small enough to get saturated evenly to impart a good flavor and large enough to stay out of the filter system.

Timing is Off

Another important thing to keep in mind is the coffee brew time. If you brew your coffee for too long or for not enough time, you’ll be left with over or under-extracted coffee. If you’re trying a new blend, then a little experimentation might be needed before you can find your perfect brew.

Leave a Comment